By Will Sterling, Partner | Chief Investment Officer

As we look ahead to 2026, investors are once again asking a familiar question: what should we expect from equity markets? After several years marked by higher interest rates, narrow market leadership, and shifting macro narratives, it is natural to seek clarity about the road ahead.

The most important starting point is also the most honest one: no one knows with certainty what markets will deliver in 2026. What we do have, however, are useful reference points — earnings expectations, valuation frameworks, and the collective views of market strategists that help frame a range of plausible outcomes. Just as importantly, history reminds us that diversification and staying invested have consistently mattered more than short-term prediction.

Strategist Expectations for 2026: Constructive, with Conditions

According to Bloomberg’s compilation of analyst and strategist forecasts, the consensus year-end 2026 target for the S&P 500 is approximately 7,465, supported by a 2026 earnings estimate of roughly $305 per share. At those levels, the market is implicitly discounting continued earnings growth with valuation multiples that remain elevated but relatively stable.

Several major institutions cluster near that consensus. Goldman Sachs, led by Ben Snider, forecasts a 12% total return for U.S. equities in 2026, with a 7,600 year-end S&P 500 target, while JPMorgan, under Dubravko Lakos-Bujas, has penned a 7,500 target. While the precise index level is less important than the path taken, these views share a common theme: returns in 2026 are expected to be driven primarily by earnings growth rather than further multiple expansion.

In fact, most strategist forecasts embed valuation assumptions similar to today’s market. Goldman’s framework, for example, assumes a forward multiple near 22x earnings, broadly in line with current levels. This suggests that upside depends less on investors paying higher prices and more on companies delivering real profit growth.

Earnings, Growth, and the Role of Policy

Underlying the consensus outlook is an expectation of continued economic expansion and a more supportive monetary policy backdrop. Strategists generally assume that the Federal Reserve will be in an easing posture in 2026, an environment that has historically been compatible with rising equity prices, particularly when growth remains intact.

On the earnings side, forecasts call for double-digit profit growth in 2026, supported by healthy revenue trends, operating leverage among large-cap companies, and incremental productivity gains from increased adoption of artificial intelligence. Importantly, these expectations are constructive but not heroic. They reflect steady progress rather than a re-acceleration to the unusually strong growth rates seen earlier in the cycle.

Valuations and the Distribution of Outcomes

While the base case remains constructive, strategists are also clear-eyed about the risks. Elevated valuations increase the range of potential outcomes, even if they do not, by themselves, cause market declines. Historically, valuation-driven drawdowns have required a catalyst — most often a growth disappointment or an unexpected interest-rate shock.

At the same time, today’s environment differs from many past late-cycle periods. Corporate balance sheets are generally healthy, household finances remain relatively strong, and financial conditions, while no longer loose, are not restrictive by historical standards. These factors help explain why strategists remain cautiously optimistic rather than defensive.

Concentration, AI, and Market Dynamics

Another widely discussed feature of today’s market is concentration. A small number of very large companies account for a historically high share of index capitalization and recent returns. Both Goldman and JP Morgan highlight this as a key dynamic to watch in 2026.

As AI investment evolves from infrastructure build-out toward broader corporate adoption, some strategists expect more stock-level rotation, particularly within large-cap technology. While aggregate earnings may remain strong, leadership within the market could shift, creating periods of volatility even if the overall trend remains positive. This environment tends to reward diversification and thoughtful portfolio construction.  However, some strategists believe 2026 positioning will resemble 2025 with new extremes in crowding and record concentration. Regardless of the environment, I believe that Harry Markowitz got it right, “Diversification is the only free lunch in investing.”

What This Means for Long-Term Investors

Periods like this can feel deceptively challenging. When markets are near highs and valuations are elevated, the temptation to “wait for a better opportunity” is understandable. Unfortunately, history suggests that waiting for clarity often results in missed returns.

Equity markets have consistently advanced over time despite wars, recessions, inflation scares, and policy mistakes. Many of the strongest market days have occurred during periods of uncertainty, not optimism. Remaining invested through those periods has historically mattered far more than correctly timing entry and exit points.

Portfolio Implications Heading into 2026

As we look ahead, our approach remains grounded in first principles:

• Diversification remains essential, particularly in a market characterized by concentration and dispersion beneath the surface.
• Equities continue to play a central role in long-term portfolios, even when short-term outcomes feel uncertain.
• Private market investments can enhance diversification and alpha. Unlike public markets, private strategies can influence outcomes through structuring, governance, and active ownership, offering differentiated return drivers and lower correlation when implemented thoughtfully.
• Discipline outweighs prediction. Forecasts will change; a well-constructed plan should not.

Final Thoughts

By most measures, 2025 was another strong year for equity investors, with the S&P 500 delivering a total return of 17.86%. The sharp 19% drawdown from February to April now feels like a distant memory, overshadowed by the market’s resilience and full-year recovery.

As we turn the page to 2026, the consensus tone across Wall Street is constructive, though it’s important to maintain perspective. Strategists tend to be optimistic: since 2000, the average year-ahead forecast has called for an 8.9% gain. Bloomberg’s current 7,465 S&P 500 consensus target implies a 9.04% price return from today’s levels, and including an estimated 1.1% dividend yield, that translates to a total return near 10.14% — another potentially solid year if expectations are met.

However, markets rarely travel in straight lines, and forecasts — no matter how well supported — are never certain. Our conviction does not rest on predicting the next 12 months with precision. It rests on the durability of a diversified, long-term portfolio, built to weather volatility and capture growth over full cycles.

That discipline — staying diversified and staying invested — remains the most reliable foundation for long-term success. While no one knows exactly what 2026 will bring, we rely on useful reference points, time-tested first principles and thoughtful planning to help our clients navigate the uncertain waters ahead.

SOURCES:

Bespoke Investment Group, “Chart of the Day – Strategist Targets for 2026”; 2026 January 2

Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research, “2026 US Equity Outlook: Great Potential”; Snider, Hammond, Ma, Chavez, Jayachandran, Sung; 2026 January 6

J.P. Morgan Global Research, “2026 Year Ahead Outlook”; 2025 December 3

Bloomberg Terminal, S&P 500 Index Analyst Recommendations; 2026 January 6

---